Why we recommend analytic treatment for some patients and not for others

Eve Caligor, Barry L. Stern, Margaret Hamilton, Verna MacCornack, Lionel Wininger, Joel Sneed, Steven P. Roose

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

20 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

One hundred consecutive patients applying for analysis completed a comprehensive battery of structured interviews and self-report questionnaires assessing dimensions of psychopathology and psychological functions that analysts consider important when evaluating patients for analysis. Patients were evaluated for analysis by a candidate supervised by a training analyst. Fifty patients were accepted for analysis and fifty rejected. In both groups, psychiatric morbidity and psychosocial impairment were high, with a 50% current and 74% lifetime diagnosis of mood disorder, 56% current and 61% lifetime history of anxiety disorder. The mean Beck Depression Inventory score fell in the moderate range, 19.1 (SD = 11.0), mean Hamilton Depression score in the mild range, 14.1 (SD = 7.8), and the mean Hamilton Anxiety score in the moderate range, 14.6 (SD = 8.1), with 57% meeting criteria for an Axis II diagnosis, and mean social adjustment in the moderate to high pathology range. Patients accepted and rejected for analysis did not differ with regard to any of these dimensions. Accepted patients scored lower on measures of impulsivity, aggression, and sociopathy, and on scores of personality rigidity, primitive defenses, and outward aggression. The major finding was the striking similarity between patients accepted and rejected for psychoanalytic treatment.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)677-694
Number of pages18
JournalJournal of the American Psychoanalytic Association
Volume57
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 1 2009
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Aggression
Therapeutics
Depression
Social Adjustment
Impulsive Behavior
Anxiety Disorders
Psychopathology
Mood Disorders
Self Report
Psychiatry
Personality
Anxiety
Interviews
Pathology
Psychology
Morbidity
Equipment and Supplies
Surveys and Questionnaires
Self-report
Impulsivity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Arts and Humanities (miscellaneous)
  • Clinical Psychology

Cite this

Why we recommend analytic treatment for some patients and not for others. / Caligor, Eve; Stern, Barry L.; Hamilton, Margaret; MacCornack, Verna; Wininger, Lionel; Sneed, Joel; Roose, Steven P.

In: Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, Vol. 57, No. 3, 01.06.2009, p. 677-694.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Caligor, Eve ; Stern, Barry L. ; Hamilton, Margaret ; MacCornack, Verna ; Wininger, Lionel ; Sneed, Joel ; Roose, Steven P. / Why we recommend analytic treatment for some patients and not for others. In: Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association. 2009 ; Vol. 57, No. 3. pp. 677-694.
@article{116f5c768a9845ad94682eed40d97a4b,
title = "Why we recommend analytic treatment for some patients and not for others",
abstract = "One hundred consecutive patients applying for analysis completed a comprehensive battery of structured interviews and self-report questionnaires assessing dimensions of psychopathology and psychological functions that analysts consider important when evaluating patients for analysis. Patients were evaluated for analysis by a candidate supervised by a training analyst. Fifty patients were accepted for analysis and fifty rejected. In both groups, psychiatric morbidity and psychosocial impairment were high, with a 50{\%} current and 74{\%} lifetime diagnosis of mood disorder, 56{\%} current and 61{\%} lifetime history of anxiety disorder. The mean Beck Depression Inventory score fell in the moderate range, 19.1 (SD = 11.0), mean Hamilton Depression score in the mild range, 14.1 (SD = 7.8), and the mean Hamilton Anxiety score in the moderate range, 14.6 (SD = 8.1), with 57{\%} meeting criteria for an Axis II diagnosis, and mean social adjustment in the moderate to high pathology range. Patients accepted and rejected for analysis did not differ with regard to any of these dimensions. Accepted patients scored lower on measures of impulsivity, aggression, and sociopathy, and on scores of personality rigidity, primitive defenses, and outward aggression. The major finding was the striking similarity between patients accepted and rejected for psychoanalytic treatment.",
author = "Eve Caligor and Stern, {Barry L.} and Margaret Hamilton and Verna MacCornack and Lionel Wininger and Joel Sneed and Roose, {Steven P.}",
year = "2009",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/0003065109337607",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "57",
pages = "677--694",
journal = "Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association",
issn = "0003-0651",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Why we recommend analytic treatment for some patients and not for others

AU - Caligor, Eve

AU - Stern, Barry L.

AU - Hamilton, Margaret

AU - MacCornack, Verna

AU - Wininger, Lionel

AU - Sneed, Joel

AU - Roose, Steven P.

PY - 2009/6/1

Y1 - 2009/6/1

N2 - One hundred consecutive patients applying for analysis completed a comprehensive battery of structured interviews and self-report questionnaires assessing dimensions of psychopathology and psychological functions that analysts consider important when evaluating patients for analysis. Patients were evaluated for analysis by a candidate supervised by a training analyst. Fifty patients were accepted for analysis and fifty rejected. In both groups, psychiatric morbidity and psychosocial impairment were high, with a 50% current and 74% lifetime diagnosis of mood disorder, 56% current and 61% lifetime history of anxiety disorder. The mean Beck Depression Inventory score fell in the moderate range, 19.1 (SD = 11.0), mean Hamilton Depression score in the mild range, 14.1 (SD = 7.8), and the mean Hamilton Anxiety score in the moderate range, 14.6 (SD = 8.1), with 57% meeting criteria for an Axis II diagnosis, and mean social adjustment in the moderate to high pathology range. Patients accepted and rejected for analysis did not differ with regard to any of these dimensions. Accepted patients scored lower on measures of impulsivity, aggression, and sociopathy, and on scores of personality rigidity, primitive defenses, and outward aggression. The major finding was the striking similarity between patients accepted and rejected for psychoanalytic treatment.

AB - One hundred consecutive patients applying for analysis completed a comprehensive battery of structured interviews and self-report questionnaires assessing dimensions of psychopathology and psychological functions that analysts consider important when evaluating patients for analysis. Patients were evaluated for analysis by a candidate supervised by a training analyst. Fifty patients were accepted for analysis and fifty rejected. In both groups, psychiatric morbidity and psychosocial impairment were high, with a 50% current and 74% lifetime diagnosis of mood disorder, 56% current and 61% lifetime history of anxiety disorder. The mean Beck Depression Inventory score fell in the moderate range, 19.1 (SD = 11.0), mean Hamilton Depression score in the mild range, 14.1 (SD = 7.8), and the mean Hamilton Anxiety score in the moderate range, 14.6 (SD = 8.1), with 57% meeting criteria for an Axis II diagnosis, and mean social adjustment in the moderate to high pathology range. Patients accepted and rejected for analysis did not differ with regard to any of these dimensions. Accepted patients scored lower on measures of impulsivity, aggression, and sociopathy, and on scores of personality rigidity, primitive defenses, and outward aggression. The major finding was the striking similarity between patients accepted and rejected for psychoanalytic treatment.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=70349324283&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=70349324283&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0003065109337607

DO - 10.1177/0003065109337607

M3 - Article

C2 - 19528542

AN - SCOPUS:70349324283

VL - 57

SP - 677

EP - 694

JO - Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association

JF - Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association

SN - 0003-0651

IS - 3

ER -