Tubefeeding and mortality in children with severe disabilities and mental retardation

David Strauss, Theodore A. Kastner, Stephen Ashwal, James White

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

67 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective. To study the contribution of tubefeeding to mortality for children with severe disabilities and mental retardation. Previous research has suggested an association between tubefeeding and mortality. However, risk has never been determined using population-based data or defined in regard to patient variables. Methods. Retrospective analysis of a comprehensive statewide data set comprised of 4921 children with severe disabilities and mental retardation living in community and congregate care settings. The outcome measure was mortality; primary study variables included the presence of a feeding tube, measures of functional independence, type of residence, and medical comorbidity. Results. There were four findings. First, the use of a feeding tube was associated with virtually every disability. Second, when no study variables were controlled, statistically significant differences in mortality rates were noted between children who were tubefed and those who were not. The relative risk of mortality associated with use of a feeding tube was 2.1. Third, the use of a feeding tube was associated with a reduction in relative risk of mortality in children with tracheostomy (relative risk of mortality: .55). However, this association did not achieve statistical significance. Fourth, when study variables were controlled in a multivariate analysis, feeding tube use was associated with no identifiable increase in mortality among children with very severe disabilities, but was associated with an approximated doubled mortality rate among those with less severe disabilities. Conclusions. We hypothesize that the increased mortality associated with tubefeeding may be attributable to a differential increase in pulmonary disease secondary to overly vigorous nutritional maintenance and subsequent aspiration after tube placement. For children with tracheostomy this risk may be reduced. If tracheostomy proves to be associated with a relatively more favorable outcome for tubefeeding, we hypothesize that it would reflect the benefits of tracheostomy in allowing access to the airway for suctioning and ventilation. Given the observed higher mortality rates among the less severely disabled children who are tubefed and the substantial costs associated with tubefeeding, a prospective, controlled study may be clinically indicated, ethically justifiable, and economically warranted.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)358-362
Number of pages5
JournalPediatrics
Volume99
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1997
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Disabled Children
Intellectual Disability
Enteral Nutrition
Mortality
Tracheostomy
Child Mortality
Lung Diseases
Ventilation
Comorbidity
Multivariate Analysis
Maintenance
Outcome Assessment (Health Care)
Prospective Studies
Costs and Cost Analysis

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pediatrics, Perinatology, and Child Health

Cite this

Tubefeeding and mortality in children with severe disabilities and mental retardation. / Strauss, David; Kastner, Theodore A.; Ashwal, Stephen; White, James.

In: Pediatrics, Vol. 99, No. 3, 03.1997, p. 358-362.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Strauss, David ; Kastner, Theodore A. ; Ashwal, Stephen ; White, James. / Tubefeeding and mortality in children with severe disabilities and mental retardation. In: Pediatrics. 1997 ; Vol. 99, No. 3. pp. 358-362.
@article{3a07dea2bf864a3baf5abd72036d7af0,
title = "Tubefeeding and mortality in children with severe disabilities and mental retardation",
abstract = "Objective. To study the contribution of tubefeeding to mortality for children with severe disabilities and mental retardation. Previous research has suggested an association between tubefeeding and mortality. However, risk has never been determined using population-based data or defined in regard to patient variables. Methods. Retrospective analysis of a comprehensive statewide data set comprised of 4921 children with severe disabilities and mental retardation living in community and congregate care settings. The outcome measure was mortality; primary study variables included the presence of a feeding tube, measures of functional independence, type of residence, and medical comorbidity. Results. There were four findings. First, the use of a feeding tube was associated with virtually every disability. Second, when no study variables were controlled, statistically significant differences in mortality rates were noted between children who were tubefed and those who were not. The relative risk of mortality associated with use of a feeding tube was 2.1. Third, the use of a feeding tube was associated with a reduction in relative risk of mortality in children with tracheostomy (relative risk of mortality: .55). However, this association did not achieve statistical significance. Fourth, when study variables were controlled in a multivariate analysis, feeding tube use was associated with no identifiable increase in mortality among children with very severe disabilities, but was associated with an approximated doubled mortality rate among those with less severe disabilities. Conclusions. We hypothesize that the increased mortality associated with tubefeeding may be attributable to a differential increase in pulmonary disease secondary to overly vigorous nutritional maintenance and subsequent aspiration after tube placement. For children with tracheostomy this risk may be reduced. If tracheostomy proves to be associated with a relatively more favorable outcome for tubefeeding, we hypothesize that it would reflect the benefits of tracheostomy in allowing access to the airway for suctioning and ventilation. Given the observed higher mortality rates among the less severely disabled children who are tubefed and the substantial costs associated with tubefeeding, a prospective, controlled study may be clinically indicated, ethically justifiable, and economically warranted.",
author = "David Strauss and Kastner, {Theodore A.} and Stephen Ashwal and James White",
year = "1997",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1542/peds.99.3.358",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "99",
pages = "358--362",
journal = "Pediatrics",
issn = "0031-4005",
publisher = "American Academy of Pediatrics",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Tubefeeding and mortality in children with severe disabilities and mental retardation

AU - Strauss, David

AU - Kastner, Theodore A.

AU - Ashwal, Stephen

AU - White, James

PY - 1997/3

Y1 - 1997/3

N2 - Objective. To study the contribution of tubefeeding to mortality for children with severe disabilities and mental retardation. Previous research has suggested an association between tubefeeding and mortality. However, risk has never been determined using population-based data or defined in regard to patient variables. Methods. Retrospective analysis of a comprehensive statewide data set comprised of 4921 children with severe disabilities and mental retardation living in community and congregate care settings. The outcome measure was mortality; primary study variables included the presence of a feeding tube, measures of functional independence, type of residence, and medical comorbidity. Results. There were four findings. First, the use of a feeding tube was associated with virtually every disability. Second, when no study variables were controlled, statistically significant differences in mortality rates were noted between children who were tubefed and those who were not. The relative risk of mortality associated with use of a feeding tube was 2.1. Third, the use of a feeding tube was associated with a reduction in relative risk of mortality in children with tracheostomy (relative risk of mortality: .55). However, this association did not achieve statistical significance. Fourth, when study variables were controlled in a multivariate analysis, feeding tube use was associated with no identifiable increase in mortality among children with very severe disabilities, but was associated with an approximated doubled mortality rate among those with less severe disabilities. Conclusions. We hypothesize that the increased mortality associated with tubefeeding may be attributable to a differential increase in pulmonary disease secondary to overly vigorous nutritional maintenance and subsequent aspiration after tube placement. For children with tracheostomy this risk may be reduced. If tracheostomy proves to be associated with a relatively more favorable outcome for tubefeeding, we hypothesize that it would reflect the benefits of tracheostomy in allowing access to the airway for suctioning and ventilation. Given the observed higher mortality rates among the less severely disabled children who are tubefed and the substantial costs associated with tubefeeding, a prospective, controlled study may be clinically indicated, ethically justifiable, and economically warranted.

AB - Objective. To study the contribution of tubefeeding to mortality for children with severe disabilities and mental retardation. Previous research has suggested an association between tubefeeding and mortality. However, risk has never been determined using population-based data or defined in regard to patient variables. Methods. Retrospective analysis of a comprehensive statewide data set comprised of 4921 children with severe disabilities and mental retardation living in community and congregate care settings. The outcome measure was mortality; primary study variables included the presence of a feeding tube, measures of functional independence, type of residence, and medical comorbidity. Results. There were four findings. First, the use of a feeding tube was associated with virtually every disability. Second, when no study variables were controlled, statistically significant differences in mortality rates were noted between children who were tubefed and those who were not. The relative risk of mortality associated with use of a feeding tube was 2.1. Third, the use of a feeding tube was associated with a reduction in relative risk of mortality in children with tracheostomy (relative risk of mortality: .55). However, this association did not achieve statistical significance. Fourth, when study variables were controlled in a multivariate analysis, feeding tube use was associated with no identifiable increase in mortality among children with very severe disabilities, but was associated with an approximated doubled mortality rate among those with less severe disabilities. Conclusions. We hypothesize that the increased mortality associated with tubefeeding may be attributable to a differential increase in pulmonary disease secondary to overly vigorous nutritional maintenance and subsequent aspiration after tube placement. For children with tracheostomy this risk may be reduced. If tracheostomy proves to be associated with a relatively more favorable outcome for tubefeeding, we hypothesize that it would reflect the benefits of tracheostomy in allowing access to the airway for suctioning and ventilation. Given the observed higher mortality rates among the less severely disabled children who are tubefed and the substantial costs associated with tubefeeding, a prospective, controlled study may be clinically indicated, ethically justifiable, and economically warranted.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0030900717&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0030900717&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1542/peds.99.3.358

DO - 10.1542/peds.99.3.358

M3 - Article

C2 - 9041288

AN - SCOPUS:0030900717

VL - 99

SP - 358

EP - 362

JO - Pediatrics

JF - Pediatrics

SN - 0031-4005

IS - 3

ER -