Repeatability of sexual history in longitudinal studies on HPV infection and cervical neoplasia: Determinants of reporting error at follow-up interviews

N. F. Schlecht, E. L. Franco, Thomas E. Rohan, S. K. Kjaer, M. H. Schiffman, A. B. Moscicki, S. W. Duffy, E. I. Svare, M. Schiffman, A. Hildesheim, R. Herrero, M. C. Bratti, A. C. Rodriguez, L. L. Villa, A. Ferenczy, T. E. Rohan, D. G. Harnish, H. Richardson, F. Coutlée, P. TellierJ. Palefsky, S. Shiboski, T. M. Darragh, N. Benowitz

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background Misclassification of sexual history due to faulty recall or reporting bias may be the reason for variability in the association between sexual history and human papillomavirus (HPV) infection seen in studies conducted in different geographical areas. This study aimed to assess the repeatability of questionnaire information on sexual-history variables and their correlates, using information from repeat interviews by six international prospective cohort studies. Methods. The pooled dataset included over 14 775 women interviewed on two separate occasions, of whom 5690 returned for a third interview. At each return visit women were re-asked questions on age at first inter-course and number of sexual partners. The six cohorts originated from studies in Denmark, Costa Rica, San Francisco, Toronto, Montreal and São Paulo. Results. Exact agreement between age at first intercourse recalled on separate occasions ranged from 60-85%, whereas exact recall rates for number of sexual partners were substantially lower and more study-dependent, varying between 20% and 77%. The intraclass correlation coefficients gauging the degree of repeatability in responses ranged from 0.68 to 0.97 for age at first intercourse and 0.08 to 0.94 for number of sexual partners. Age, ethnicity, education and cohort membership were the strongest predictors of reporting error for both sexual history markers, although study design characteristics also seemed to play a role. HPV infection status seemed to influence recall of number of partners, but not age at first intercourse. Conclusions. Information on sexual behaviours is not reliably collected in epidemiological studies of sexually transmitted diseases, which may influence the magnitude of relative risk estimates.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)393-407
Number of pages15
JournalJournal of Epidemiology and Biostatistics
Volume6
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - 2001
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Papillomavirus Infections
Sexual Partners
Coitus
Longitudinal Studies
Interviews
Cohort Studies
Costa Rica
Neoplasms
San Francisco
Denmark
Sexually Transmitted Diseases
Sexual Behavior
Epidemiologic Studies
History
Prospective Studies
Education

Keywords

  • Cervical neoplasia
  • Cohort studies
  • Human papillomavirus
  • Information bias
  • Misclassification
  • Sexual behaviour

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Epidemiology

Cite this

Repeatability of sexual history in longitudinal studies on HPV infection and cervical neoplasia : Determinants of reporting error at follow-up interviews. / Schlecht, N. F.; Franco, E. L.; Rohan, Thomas E.; Kjaer, S. K.; Schiffman, M. H.; Moscicki, A. B.; Duffy, S. W.; Svare, E. I.; Schiffman, M.; Hildesheim, A.; Herrero, R.; Bratti, M. C.; Rodriguez, A. C.; Villa, L. L.; Ferenczy, A.; Rohan, T. E.; Harnish, D. G.; Richardson, H.; Coutlée, F.; Tellier, P.; Palefsky, J.; Shiboski, S.; Darragh, T. M.; Benowitz, N.

In: Journal of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Vol. 6, No. 5, 2001, p. 393-407.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Schlecht, NF, Franco, EL, Rohan, TE, Kjaer, SK, Schiffman, MH, Moscicki, AB, Duffy, SW, Svare, EI, Schiffman, M, Hildesheim, A, Herrero, R, Bratti, MC, Rodriguez, AC, Villa, LL, Ferenczy, A, Rohan, TE, Harnish, DG, Richardson, H, Coutlée, F, Tellier, P, Palefsky, J, Shiboski, S, Darragh, TM & Benowitz, N 2001, 'Repeatability of sexual history in longitudinal studies on HPV infection and cervical neoplasia: Determinants of reporting error at follow-up interviews', Journal of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, vol. 6, no. 5, pp. 393-407. https://doi.org/10.1080/135952201753337149
Schlecht, N. F. ; Franco, E. L. ; Rohan, Thomas E. ; Kjaer, S. K. ; Schiffman, M. H. ; Moscicki, A. B. ; Duffy, S. W. ; Svare, E. I. ; Schiffman, M. ; Hildesheim, A. ; Herrero, R. ; Bratti, M. C. ; Rodriguez, A. C. ; Villa, L. L. ; Ferenczy, A. ; Rohan, T. E. ; Harnish, D. G. ; Richardson, H. ; Coutlée, F. ; Tellier, P. ; Palefsky, J. ; Shiboski, S. ; Darragh, T. M. ; Benowitz, N. / Repeatability of sexual history in longitudinal studies on HPV infection and cervical neoplasia : Determinants of reporting error at follow-up interviews. In: Journal of Epidemiology and Biostatistics. 2001 ; Vol. 6, No. 5. pp. 393-407.
@article{120670afb41e48bf8e10b8fd2214ed60,
title = "Repeatability of sexual history in longitudinal studies on HPV infection and cervical neoplasia: Determinants of reporting error at follow-up interviews",
abstract = "Background Misclassification of sexual history due to faulty recall or reporting bias may be the reason for variability in the association between sexual history and human papillomavirus (HPV) infection seen in studies conducted in different geographical areas. This study aimed to assess the repeatability of questionnaire information on sexual-history variables and their correlates, using information from repeat interviews by six international prospective cohort studies. Methods. The pooled dataset included over 14 775 women interviewed on two separate occasions, of whom 5690 returned for a third interview. At each return visit women were re-asked questions on age at first inter-course and number of sexual partners. The six cohorts originated from studies in Denmark, Costa Rica, San Francisco, Toronto, Montreal and S{\~a}o Paulo. Results. Exact agreement between age at first intercourse recalled on separate occasions ranged from 60-85{\%}, whereas exact recall rates for number of sexual partners were substantially lower and more study-dependent, varying between 20{\%} and 77{\%}. The intraclass correlation coefficients gauging the degree of repeatability in responses ranged from 0.68 to 0.97 for age at first intercourse and 0.08 to 0.94 for number of sexual partners. Age, ethnicity, education and cohort membership were the strongest predictors of reporting error for both sexual history markers, although study design characteristics also seemed to play a role. HPV infection status seemed to influence recall of number of partners, but not age at first intercourse. Conclusions. Information on sexual behaviours is not reliably collected in epidemiological studies of sexually transmitted diseases, which may influence the magnitude of relative risk estimates.",
keywords = "Cervical neoplasia, Cohort studies, Human papillomavirus, Information bias, Misclassification, Sexual behaviour",
author = "Schlecht, {N. F.} and Franco, {E. L.} and Rohan, {Thomas E.} and Kjaer, {S. K.} and Schiffman, {M. H.} and Moscicki, {A. B.} and Duffy, {S. W.} and Svare, {E. I.} and M. Schiffman and A. Hildesheim and R. Herrero and Bratti, {M. C.} and Rodriguez, {A. C.} and Villa, {L. L.} and A. Ferenczy and Rohan, {T. E.} and Harnish, {D. G.} and H. Richardson and F. Coutl{\'e}e and P. Tellier and J. Palefsky and S. Shiboski and Darragh, {T. M.} and N. Benowitz",
year = "2001",
doi = "10.1080/135952201753337149",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "6",
pages = "393--407",
journal = "Journal of Epidemiology and Biostatistics",
issn = "1359-5229",
publisher = "Isis Medical Media Ltd.",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Repeatability of sexual history in longitudinal studies on HPV infection and cervical neoplasia

T2 - Determinants of reporting error at follow-up interviews

AU - Schlecht, N. F.

AU - Franco, E. L.

AU - Rohan, Thomas E.

AU - Kjaer, S. K.

AU - Schiffman, M. H.

AU - Moscicki, A. B.

AU - Duffy, S. W.

AU - Svare, E. I.

AU - Schiffman, M.

AU - Hildesheim, A.

AU - Herrero, R.

AU - Bratti, M. C.

AU - Rodriguez, A. C.

AU - Villa, L. L.

AU - Ferenczy, A.

AU - Rohan, T. E.

AU - Harnish, D. G.

AU - Richardson, H.

AU - Coutlée, F.

AU - Tellier, P.

AU - Palefsky, J.

AU - Shiboski, S.

AU - Darragh, T. M.

AU - Benowitz, N.

PY - 2001

Y1 - 2001

N2 - Background Misclassification of sexual history due to faulty recall or reporting bias may be the reason for variability in the association between sexual history and human papillomavirus (HPV) infection seen in studies conducted in different geographical areas. This study aimed to assess the repeatability of questionnaire information on sexual-history variables and their correlates, using information from repeat interviews by six international prospective cohort studies. Methods. The pooled dataset included over 14 775 women interviewed on two separate occasions, of whom 5690 returned for a third interview. At each return visit women were re-asked questions on age at first inter-course and number of sexual partners. The six cohorts originated from studies in Denmark, Costa Rica, San Francisco, Toronto, Montreal and São Paulo. Results. Exact agreement between age at first intercourse recalled on separate occasions ranged from 60-85%, whereas exact recall rates for number of sexual partners were substantially lower and more study-dependent, varying between 20% and 77%. The intraclass correlation coefficients gauging the degree of repeatability in responses ranged from 0.68 to 0.97 for age at first intercourse and 0.08 to 0.94 for number of sexual partners. Age, ethnicity, education and cohort membership were the strongest predictors of reporting error for both sexual history markers, although study design characteristics also seemed to play a role. HPV infection status seemed to influence recall of number of partners, but not age at first intercourse. Conclusions. Information on sexual behaviours is not reliably collected in epidemiological studies of sexually transmitted diseases, which may influence the magnitude of relative risk estimates.

AB - Background Misclassification of sexual history due to faulty recall or reporting bias may be the reason for variability in the association between sexual history and human papillomavirus (HPV) infection seen in studies conducted in different geographical areas. This study aimed to assess the repeatability of questionnaire information on sexual-history variables and their correlates, using information from repeat interviews by six international prospective cohort studies. Methods. The pooled dataset included over 14 775 women interviewed on two separate occasions, of whom 5690 returned for a third interview. At each return visit women were re-asked questions on age at first inter-course and number of sexual partners. The six cohorts originated from studies in Denmark, Costa Rica, San Francisco, Toronto, Montreal and São Paulo. Results. Exact agreement between age at first intercourse recalled on separate occasions ranged from 60-85%, whereas exact recall rates for number of sexual partners were substantially lower and more study-dependent, varying between 20% and 77%. The intraclass correlation coefficients gauging the degree of repeatability in responses ranged from 0.68 to 0.97 for age at first intercourse and 0.08 to 0.94 for number of sexual partners. Age, ethnicity, education and cohort membership were the strongest predictors of reporting error for both sexual history markers, although study design characteristics also seemed to play a role. HPV infection status seemed to influence recall of number of partners, but not age at first intercourse. Conclusions. Information on sexual behaviours is not reliably collected in epidemiological studies of sexually transmitted diseases, which may influence the magnitude of relative risk estimates.

KW - Cervical neoplasia

KW - Cohort studies

KW - Human papillomavirus

KW - Information bias

KW - Misclassification

KW - Sexual behaviour

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=17944363584&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=17944363584&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/135952201753337149

DO - 10.1080/135952201753337149

M3 - Article

C2 - 11822729

AN - SCOPUS:17944363584

VL - 6

SP - 393

EP - 407

JO - Journal of Epidemiology and Biostatistics

JF - Journal of Epidemiology and Biostatistics

SN - 1359-5229

IS - 5

ER -