International research: Ethical Imperialism or ethical pluralism?

Ruth Macklin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Conflicts have arisen in international research when countries in which research is being carried out lack the ethical rules or mechanisms for review employed in the United States and Europe. It is objected that a requirement to adhere to regulations promulgated by the US government constitutes "ethical imperialism." But if researchers in some countries need not be bound by ethical standards widely accepted in the conduct of research, it could open the door to an ethical relativism allowing virtually any standard a country desires to accept. One example is the variations in informed consent, especially in countries that accord lesser importance to the individual than do the US and Europe. A recent controversy centered on a series of placebo-controlled, HIV/AIDS trials sponsored by the United States and conducted in several developing countries. These trials could not ethically be carried out in the United States because a proven effective treatment exists. Attempts to avoid similar controversies in forthcoming HIV/AIDS vaccine trials have been initiated by the joint United Nations AIDS program, with a process of regional consultations in the countries where the research will be conducted.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)59-83
Number of pages25
JournalAccountability in Research
Volume7
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - 1999

Fingerprint

imperialism
pluralism
AIDS
relativism
UNO
developing country
regulation
lack

Keywords

  • Declaration of Helsinki
  • Ethical imperialism
  • HIV/AIDS
  • Informed consent
  • International research

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education
  • Library and Information Sciences

Cite this

International research : Ethical Imperialism or ethical pluralism? / Macklin, Ruth.

In: Accountability in Research, Vol. 7, No. 1, 1999, p. 59-83.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{cb144669d1ae49689db3012be60d6c2b,
title = "International research: Ethical Imperialism or ethical pluralism?",
abstract = "Conflicts have arisen in international research when countries in which research is being carried out lack the ethical rules or mechanisms for review employed in the United States and Europe. It is objected that a requirement to adhere to regulations promulgated by the US government constitutes {"}ethical imperialism.{"} But if researchers in some countries need not be bound by ethical standards widely accepted in the conduct of research, it could open the door to an ethical relativism allowing virtually any standard a country desires to accept. One example is the variations in informed consent, especially in countries that accord lesser importance to the individual than do the US and Europe. A recent controversy centered on a series of placebo-controlled, HIV/AIDS trials sponsored by the United States and conducted in several developing countries. These trials could not ethically be carried out in the United States because a proven effective treatment exists. Attempts to avoid similar controversies in forthcoming HIV/AIDS vaccine trials have been initiated by the joint United Nations AIDS program, with a process of regional consultations in the countries where the research will be conducted.",
keywords = "Declaration of Helsinki, Ethical imperialism, HIV/AIDS, Informed consent, International research",
author = "Ruth Macklin",
year = "1999",
doi = "10.1080/08989629908573942",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "7",
pages = "59--83",
journal = "Accountability in Research",
issn = "0898-9621",
publisher = "Taylor and Francis Ltd.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - International research

T2 - Ethical Imperialism or ethical pluralism?

AU - Macklin, Ruth

PY - 1999

Y1 - 1999

N2 - Conflicts have arisen in international research when countries in which research is being carried out lack the ethical rules or mechanisms for review employed in the United States and Europe. It is objected that a requirement to adhere to regulations promulgated by the US government constitutes "ethical imperialism." But if researchers in some countries need not be bound by ethical standards widely accepted in the conduct of research, it could open the door to an ethical relativism allowing virtually any standard a country desires to accept. One example is the variations in informed consent, especially in countries that accord lesser importance to the individual than do the US and Europe. A recent controversy centered on a series of placebo-controlled, HIV/AIDS trials sponsored by the United States and conducted in several developing countries. These trials could not ethically be carried out in the United States because a proven effective treatment exists. Attempts to avoid similar controversies in forthcoming HIV/AIDS vaccine trials have been initiated by the joint United Nations AIDS program, with a process of regional consultations in the countries where the research will be conducted.

AB - Conflicts have arisen in international research when countries in which research is being carried out lack the ethical rules or mechanisms for review employed in the United States and Europe. It is objected that a requirement to adhere to regulations promulgated by the US government constitutes "ethical imperialism." But if researchers in some countries need not be bound by ethical standards widely accepted in the conduct of research, it could open the door to an ethical relativism allowing virtually any standard a country desires to accept. One example is the variations in informed consent, especially in countries that accord lesser importance to the individual than do the US and Europe. A recent controversy centered on a series of placebo-controlled, HIV/AIDS trials sponsored by the United States and conducted in several developing countries. These trials could not ethically be carried out in the United States because a proven effective treatment exists. Attempts to avoid similar controversies in forthcoming HIV/AIDS vaccine trials have been initiated by the joint United Nations AIDS program, with a process of regional consultations in the countries where the research will be conducted.

KW - Declaration of Helsinki

KW - Ethical imperialism

KW - HIV/AIDS

KW - Informed consent

KW - International research

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0033286343&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0033286343&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/08989629908573942

DO - 10.1080/08989629908573942

M3 - Article

C2 - 11657563

AN - SCOPUS:0033286343

VL - 7

SP - 59

EP - 83

JO - Accountability in Research

JF - Accountability in Research

SN - 0898-9621

IS - 1

ER -