Comparison of MPEG digital image compression with super VHS for diagnostic echocardiographic readings

Rupinder Brar, Gary Yurow, Alex Neumann, Thomas Stamos, Mario J. Garcia, Marcus Stoddard, P. K. Cherian, James D. Thomas, Jeffrey S. Soble

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Image compression is important to digital echocardiography, given network and storage constraints, but may adversely affect image quality. We investigated the diagnostic quality of the MPEG-1 (Motion Picture Experts Group) digital video compression standard relative to superVHS video (sVHS). Methods: 60 consecutive clinical studies (M-mode, 2D, spectral and color Doppler) were recorded simultaneously by sVHS and MPEG-1 (1.36 megabits/sec) Each study pair was reviewed and reported using a standardized computer system, containing over 500 possible diagnostic responses across the entire range of echo findings, with a >2 week interval between viewing the corresponding MPEG and sVHS recordings. In 50 study pairs, discrepancies were analyzed by two consensus readers who reviewed both the MPEG and sVHS recordings blinded to the origin of the inital reader's results. Results: On average, there were 23 diagnostic responses per study, with an overall exact concordance rate between MPEG and sVHS of approximately 84%. Of 207 discrepancies in the subset of 50 paired readings, consensus review agreed with MPEG in 106 cases and with sVHS in 101 cases (p=0.79). Of 13 discrepancies involving regional LV wall motion, consensus review agreed with MPEG in 7 cases and sVHS in 6 cases (p=1.0). Conclusion: MPEG-1 video compression yields overall diagnostic echo image quality equivalent to sVHS. Given the narrow bandwidth requirements (high compression ratio) and widespread availability of MPEG encoders and decoders, this represents an important compression strategy for digital echocardiography.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)409
Number of pages1
JournalJournal of the American Society of Echocardiography
Volume10
Issue number4
StatePublished - 1997
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Data Compression
Reading
Video Recording
Echocardiography
monomethoxypolyethylene glycol
Computer Systems
Motion Pictures
Color

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging
  • Cardiology and Cardiovascular Medicine

Cite this

Comparison of MPEG digital image compression with super VHS for diagnostic echocardiographic readings. / Brar, Rupinder; Yurow, Gary; Neumann, Alex; Stamos, Thomas; Garcia, Mario J.; Stoddard, Marcus; Cherian, P. K.; Thomas, James D.; Soble, Jeffrey S.

In: Journal of the American Society of Echocardiography, Vol. 10, No. 4, 1997, p. 409.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Brar, R, Yurow, G, Neumann, A, Stamos, T, Garcia, MJ, Stoddard, M, Cherian, PK, Thomas, JD & Soble, JS 1997, 'Comparison of MPEG digital image compression with super VHS for diagnostic echocardiographic readings', Journal of the American Society of Echocardiography, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 409.
Brar, Rupinder ; Yurow, Gary ; Neumann, Alex ; Stamos, Thomas ; Garcia, Mario J. ; Stoddard, Marcus ; Cherian, P. K. ; Thomas, James D. ; Soble, Jeffrey S. / Comparison of MPEG digital image compression with super VHS for diagnostic echocardiographic readings. In: Journal of the American Society of Echocardiography. 1997 ; Vol. 10, No. 4. pp. 409.
@article{6d544ca7e95d40b493d45b08f8cbd7d5,
title = "Comparison of MPEG digital image compression with super VHS for diagnostic echocardiographic readings",
abstract = "Image compression is important to digital echocardiography, given network and storage constraints, but may adversely affect image quality. We investigated the diagnostic quality of the MPEG-1 (Motion Picture Experts Group) digital video compression standard relative to superVHS video (sVHS). Methods: 60 consecutive clinical studies (M-mode, 2D, spectral and color Doppler) were recorded simultaneously by sVHS and MPEG-1 (1.36 megabits/sec) Each study pair was reviewed and reported using a standardized computer system, containing over 500 possible diagnostic responses across the entire range of echo findings, with a >2 week interval between viewing the corresponding MPEG and sVHS recordings. In 50 study pairs, discrepancies were analyzed by two consensus readers who reviewed both the MPEG and sVHS recordings blinded to the origin of the inital reader's results. Results: On average, there were 23 diagnostic responses per study, with an overall exact concordance rate between MPEG and sVHS of approximately 84{\%}. Of 207 discrepancies in the subset of 50 paired readings, consensus review agreed with MPEG in 106 cases and with sVHS in 101 cases (p=0.79). Of 13 discrepancies involving regional LV wall motion, consensus review agreed with MPEG in 7 cases and sVHS in 6 cases (p=1.0). Conclusion: MPEG-1 video compression yields overall diagnostic echo image quality equivalent to sVHS. Given the narrow bandwidth requirements (high compression ratio) and widespread availability of MPEG encoders and decoders, this represents an important compression strategy for digital echocardiography.",
author = "Rupinder Brar and Gary Yurow and Alex Neumann and Thomas Stamos and Garcia, {Mario J.} and Marcus Stoddard and Cherian, {P. K.} and Thomas, {James D.} and Soble, {Jeffrey S.}",
year = "1997",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "10",
pages = "409",
journal = "Journal of the American Society of Echocardiography",
issn = "0894-7317",
publisher = "Mosby Inc.",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of MPEG digital image compression with super VHS for diagnostic echocardiographic readings

AU - Brar, Rupinder

AU - Yurow, Gary

AU - Neumann, Alex

AU - Stamos, Thomas

AU - Garcia, Mario J.

AU - Stoddard, Marcus

AU - Cherian, P. K.

AU - Thomas, James D.

AU - Soble, Jeffrey S.

PY - 1997

Y1 - 1997

N2 - Image compression is important to digital echocardiography, given network and storage constraints, but may adversely affect image quality. We investigated the diagnostic quality of the MPEG-1 (Motion Picture Experts Group) digital video compression standard relative to superVHS video (sVHS). Methods: 60 consecutive clinical studies (M-mode, 2D, spectral and color Doppler) were recorded simultaneously by sVHS and MPEG-1 (1.36 megabits/sec) Each study pair was reviewed and reported using a standardized computer system, containing over 500 possible diagnostic responses across the entire range of echo findings, with a >2 week interval between viewing the corresponding MPEG and sVHS recordings. In 50 study pairs, discrepancies were analyzed by two consensus readers who reviewed both the MPEG and sVHS recordings blinded to the origin of the inital reader's results. Results: On average, there were 23 diagnostic responses per study, with an overall exact concordance rate between MPEG and sVHS of approximately 84%. Of 207 discrepancies in the subset of 50 paired readings, consensus review agreed with MPEG in 106 cases and with sVHS in 101 cases (p=0.79). Of 13 discrepancies involving regional LV wall motion, consensus review agreed with MPEG in 7 cases and sVHS in 6 cases (p=1.0). Conclusion: MPEG-1 video compression yields overall diagnostic echo image quality equivalent to sVHS. Given the narrow bandwidth requirements (high compression ratio) and widespread availability of MPEG encoders and decoders, this represents an important compression strategy for digital echocardiography.

AB - Image compression is important to digital echocardiography, given network and storage constraints, but may adversely affect image quality. We investigated the diagnostic quality of the MPEG-1 (Motion Picture Experts Group) digital video compression standard relative to superVHS video (sVHS). Methods: 60 consecutive clinical studies (M-mode, 2D, spectral and color Doppler) were recorded simultaneously by sVHS and MPEG-1 (1.36 megabits/sec) Each study pair was reviewed and reported using a standardized computer system, containing over 500 possible diagnostic responses across the entire range of echo findings, with a >2 week interval between viewing the corresponding MPEG and sVHS recordings. In 50 study pairs, discrepancies were analyzed by two consensus readers who reviewed both the MPEG and sVHS recordings blinded to the origin of the inital reader's results. Results: On average, there were 23 diagnostic responses per study, with an overall exact concordance rate between MPEG and sVHS of approximately 84%. Of 207 discrepancies in the subset of 50 paired readings, consensus review agreed with MPEG in 106 cases and with sVHS in 101 cases (p=0.79). Of 13 discrepancies involving regional LV wall motion, consensus review agreed with MPEG in 7 cases and sVHS in 6 cases (p=1.0). Conclusion: MPEG-1 video compression yields overall diagnostic echo image quality equivalent to sVHS. Given the narrow bandwidth requirements (high compression ratio) and widespread availability of MPEG encoders and decoders, this represents an important compression strategy for digital echocardiography.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=2342574665&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=2342574665&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:2342574665

VL - 10

SP - 409

JO - Journal of the American Society of Echocardiography

JF - Journal of the American Society of Echocardiography

SN - 0894-7317

IS - 4

ER -