Theory and practice in psychotherapy some contradictions in expressed belief and reported practice

Peter Buckley, Toksoz B. Karasu, Edward Charles, Stefan P. Stein

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Anecdotal reports from psychotherapists frequently suggest that theoretical guidelines are not readily adhered to in actual practice. Previous studies have found marked differences in viewpoint on many aspects of technique and practice among even relatively homogeneous groups of psychotherapists. In order to explore further the discrepancies between specific theoretical issues in psychotherapy and their practical clinical applications, the authors surveyed a large group of experienced, practicing psychodynamic psychotherapists. A comprehensive questionnaire addressing theoretical issues such as transference, countertransference, and goals of therapy was constructed. In all there were 70 items and respondents were requested to rate each item in terms of psychotherapy “as you practice it.” Numerous discrepancies between theoretical belief and clinical practice were found. Almost all of the 81 respondents agreed that the therapist should not impose his value system on the patient, yet half of the group viewed the therapist’s encouragement of the enrichment of the patient’s social life and encouragement of educational and vocational pursuits as an important aspect of the therapy. A significant number agreed that giving suggestions and advice to the patient may be harmful, but an equal number felt that the therapist should encourage more adaptive modes of behavior including sexual intimacy in the patient’s outside life. Marked disagreements were found over issues of dependency, controlling the patient’s outside behavior, and the development of countertransference feelings. Analysis of the data by age revealed that older therapists allowed themselves to be more liberal in their attitudes to such issues as the development of dependency by the patient, the promotion of the enrichment of the patient’s social life and the development of countertransference than younger therapists. This study confirmed the presence of striking discrepancies between theoretical belief and clinical practice in dynamic psychotherapy.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)218-223
Number of pages6
JournalJournal of Nervous and Mental Disease
Volume167
Issue number4
StatePublished - 1979

Fingerprint

Psychotherapy
Psychological Adaptation
Emotions
Guidelines
Therapeutics
Countertransference (Psychology)
Surveys and Questionnaires

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Psychiatry and Mental health

Cite this

Theory and practice in psychotherapy some contradictions in expressed belief and reported practice. / Buckley, Peter; Karasu, Toksoz B.; Charles, Edward; Stein, Stefan P.

In: Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, Vol. 167, No. 4, 1979, p. 218-223.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Buckley, Peter ; Karasu, Toksoz B. ; Charles, Edward ; Stein, Stefan P. / Theory and practice in psychotherapy some contradictions in expressed belief and reported practice. In: Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease. 1979 ; Vol. 167, No. 4. pp. 218-223.
@article{bd040a5969424d26808d67c31326a482,
title = "Theory and practice in psychotherapy some contradictions in expressed belief and reported practice",
abstract = "Anecdotal reports from psychotherapists frequently suggest that theoretical guidelines are not readily adhered to in actual practice. Previous studies have found marked differences in viewpoint on many aspects of technique and practice among even relatively homogeneous groups of psychotherapists. In order to explore further the discrepancies between specific theoretical issues in psychotherapy and their practical clinical applications, the authors surveyed a large group of experienced, practicing psychodynamic psychotherapists. A comprehensive questionnaire addressing theoretical issues such as transference, countertransference, and goals of therapy was constructed. In all there were 70 items and respondents were requested to rate each item in terms of psychotherapy “as you practice it.” Numerous discrepancies between theoretical belief and clinical practice were found. Almost all of the 81 respondents agreed that the therapist should not impose his value system on the patient, yet half of the group viewed the therapist’s encouragement of the enrichment of the patient’s social life and encouragement of educational and vocational pursuits as an important aspect of the therapy. A significant number agreed that giving suggestions and advice to the patient may be harmful, but an equal number felt that the therapist should encourage more adaptive modes of behavior including sexual intimacy in the patient’s outside life. Marked disagreements were found over issues of dependency, controlling the patient’s outside behavior, and the development of countertransference feelings. Analysis of the data by age revealed that older therapists allowed themselves to be more liberal in their attitudes to such issues as the development of dependency by the patient, the promotion of the enrichment of the patient’s social life and the development of countertransference than younger therapists. This study confirmed the presence of striking discrepancies between theoretical belief and clinical practice in dynamic psychotherapy.",
author = "Peter Buckley and Karasu, {Toksoz B.} and Edward Charles and Stein, {Stefan P.}",
year = "1979",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "167",
pages = "218--223",
journal = "Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease",
issn = "0022-3018",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Theory and practice in psychotherapy some contradictions in expressed belief and reported practice

AU - Buckley, Peter

AU - Karasu, Toksoz B.

AU - Charles, Edward

AU - Stein, Stefan P.

PY - 1979

Y1 - 1979

N2 - Anecdotal reports from psychotherapists frequently suggest that theoretical guidelines are not readily adhered to in actual practice. Previous studies have found marked differences in viewpoint on many aspects of technique and practice among even relatively homogeneous groups of psychotherapists. In order to explore further the discrepancies between specific theoretical issues in psychotherapy and their practical clinical applications, the authors surveyed a large group of experienced, practicing psychodynamic psychotherapists. A comprehensive questionnaire addressing theoretical issues such as transference, countertransference, and goals of therapy was constructed. In all there were 70 items and respondents were requested to rate each item in terms of psychotherapy “as you practice it.” Numerous discrepancies between theoretical belief and clinical practice were found. Almost all of the 81 respondents agreed that the therapist should not impose his value system on the patient, yet half of the group viewed the therapist’s encouragement of the enrichment of the patient’s social life and encouragement of educational and vocational pursuits as an important aspect of the therapy. A significant number agreed that giving suggestions and advice to the patient may be harmful, but an equal number felt that the therapist should encourage more adaptive modes of behavior including sexual intimacy in the patient’s outside life. Marked disagreements were found over issues of dependency, controlling the patient’s outside behavior, and the development of countertransference feelings. Analysis of the data by age revealed that older therapists allowed themselves to be more liberal in their attitudes to such issues as the development of dependency by the patient, the promotion of the enrichment of the patient’s social life and the development of countertransference than younger therapists. This study confirmed the presence of striking discrepancies between theoretical belief and clinical practice in dynamic psychotherapy.

AB - Anecdotal reports from psychotherapists frequently suggest that theoretical guidelines are not readily adhered to in actual practice. Previous studies have found marked differences in viewpoint on many aspects of technique and practice among even relatively homogeneous groups of psychotherapists. In order to explore further the discrepancies between specific theoretical issues in psychotherapy and their practical clinical applications, the authors surveyed a large group of experienced, practicing psychodynamic psychotherapists. A comprehensive questionnaire addressing theoretical issues such as transference, countertransference, and goals of therapy was constructed. In all there were 70 items and respondents were requested to rate each item in terms of psychotherapy “as you practice it.” Numerous discrepancies between theoretical belief and clinical practice were found. Almost all of the 81 respondents agreed that the therapist should not impose his value system on the patient, yet half of the group viewed the therapist’s encouragement of the enrichment of the patient’s social life and encouragement of educational and vocational pursuits as an important aspect of the therapy. A significant number agreed that giving suggestions and advice to the patient may be harmful, but an equal number felt that the therapist should encourage more adaptive modes of behavior including sexual intimacy in the patient’s outside life. Marked disagreements were found over issues of dependency, controlling the patient’s outside behavior, and the development of countertransference feelings. Analysis of the data by age revealed that older therapists allowed themselves to be more liberal in their attitudes to such issues as the development of dependency by the patient, the promotion of the enrichment of the patient’s social life and the development of countertransference than younger therapists. This study confirmed the presence of striking discrepancies between theoretical belief and clinical practice in dynamic psychotherapy.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0018361046&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0018361046&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 438792

AN - SCOPUS:0018361046

VL - 167

SP - 218

EP - 223

JO - Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease

JF - Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease

SN - 0022-3018

IS - 4

ER -