Long-term follow-up of pacemaker lead systems

Establishment of standards of quality

S. Furman, Z. M. Benedek, Carolyn A. Andrews, Jay N. Gross, R. Ritacco

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

18 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The functional details of all 5,405 pacemaker leads implanted on Montefiore Medical Center were contemporaneously recorded between 1960 and May 31, 1993. Some models have been observed for as long as 24 years. Ventricular leads with more than 50 and atrial leads with more than 30 implanted units have been continually and repeatedly subjected to actuarial cumulative survival rate (CSR) analysis during which clinical decisions, such as continued lead implantation, cessation of use, or early withdrawal from service, were made. CSR evaluation for many lead models by the Mantel- Haenszel method allowed comparison of the performance of contemporaneous lead models with older and new technologies. No effect on lead longevity, durability, on mode of end of lead service, lead removal independent of function (e.g., for infection), materials, or physiological failure was found due to an operator or anatomical route of venous access. Multifilar silicone rubber insulated leads have longevity (CSR) superior to monofilar silicone rubber leads. The cumulative survival of silicone rubber insulated monofilar models 6901, 6907, continuous lead (CL), 4 mm, and 2 mm was 79%-91%, 20 years after implantation. Multifilar silicone rubber insulated models 6961 and 4116 had a cumulative survival of 99%-100%, 15 years after implantation. Among multifilar polyurethane insulated leads, distinct longevity differences exist between formulations and contemporaneous models that are normally similar, yielding a bimodal longevity distinction; model 6971 (ventricular) has 95% CSR and 6991U (atrial) has 94% CSR, 10 years after implantation. Both performed less well than other contemporaneous models, which approximate 100% CSR. The 10-year CSR for leads implanted between 1960-1975 (Era 1) is 98.7%, and the 10-year CSR of leads implanted between 1981-1985 (Era 3) is 99.4%. Comparison of individual lead models, and all leads of specific eras, allows development of survival expectations and standards of quality for comparison between contemporaneous lead models and different eras of manufacture. As the highest available lead CSR sets the standard, statistical deviation era model from the best performance of a specific era should be considered as an indication of reduced quality.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)271-285
Number of pages15
JournalPACE - Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology
Volume18
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - 1995

Fingerprint

Silicone Elastomers
Polyurethanes
Lead
Survival Analysis
Technology
Infection

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Cardiology and Cardiovascular Medicine

Cite this

Long-term follow-up of pacemaker lead systems : Establishment of standards of quality. / Furman, S.; Benedek, Z. M.; Andrews, Carolyn A.; Gross, Jay N.; Ritacco, R.

In: PACE - Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology, Vol. 18, No. 2, 1995, p. 271-285.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{ea19d87ee8d844d3ab9eb5e10d126903,
title = "Long-term follow-up of pacemaker lead systems: Establishment of standards of quality",
abstract = "The functional details of all 5,405 pacemaker leads implanted on Montefiore Medical Center were contemporaneously recorded between 1960 and May 31, 1993. Some models have been observed for as long as 24 years. Ventricular leads with more than 50 and atrial leads with more than 30 implanted units have been continually and repeatedly subjected to actuarial cumulative survival rate (CSR) analysis during which clinical decisions, such as continued lead implantation, cessation of use, or early withdrawal from service, were made. CSR evaluation for many lead models by the Mantel- Haenszel method allowed comparison of the performance of contemporaneous lead models with older and new technologies. No effect on lead longevity, durability, on mode of end of lead service, lead removal independent of function (e.g., for infection), materials, or physiological failure was found due to an operator or anatomical route of venous access. Multifilar silicone rubber insulated leads have longevity (CSR) superior to monofilar silicone rubber leads. The cumulative survival of silicone rubber insulated monofilar models 6901, 6907, continuous lead (CL), 4 mm, and 2 mm was 79{\%}-91{\%}, 20 years after implantation. Multifilar silicone rubber insulated models 6961 and 4116 had a cumulative survival of 99{\%}-100{\%}, 15 years after implantation. Among multifilar polyurethane insulated leads, distinct longevity differences exist between formulations and contemporaneous models that are normally similar, yielding a bimodal longevity distinction; model 6971 (ventricular) has 95{\%} CSR and 6991U (atrial) has 94{\%} CSR, 10 years after implantation. Both performed less well than other contemporaneous models, which approximate 100{\%} CSR. The 10-year CSR for leads implanted between 1960-1975 (Era 1) is 98.7{\%}, and the 10-year CSR of leads implanted between 1981-1985 (Era 3) is 99.4{\%}. Comparison of individual lead models, and all leads of specific eras, allows development of survival expectations and standards of quality for comparison between contemporaneous lead models and different eras of manufacture. As the highest available lead CSR sets the standard, statistical deviation era model from the best performance of a specific era should be considered as an indication of reduced quality.",
author = "S. Furman and Benedek, {Z. M.} and Andrews, {Carolyn A.} and Gross, {Jay N.} and R. Ritacco",
year = "1995",
doi = "10.1111/j.1540-8159.1995.tb02517.x",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "18",
pages = "271--285",
journal = "PACE - Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology",
issn = "0147-8389",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Long-term follow-up of pacemaker lead systems

T2 - Establishment of standards of quality

AU - Furman, S.

AU - Benedek, Z. M.

AU - Andrews, Carolyn A.

AU - Gross, Jay N.

AU - Ritacco, R.

PY - 1995

Y1 - 1995

N2 - The functional details of all 5,405 pacemaker leads implanted on Montefiore Medical Center were contemporaneously recorded between 1960 and May 31, 1993. Some models have been observed for as long as 24 years. Ventricular leads with more than 50 and atrial leads with more than 30 implanted units have been continually and repeatedly subjected to actuarial cumulative survival rate (CSR) analysis during which clinical decisions, such as continued lead implantation, cessation of use, or early withdrawal from service, were made. CSR evaluation for many lead models by the Mantel- Haenszel method allowed comparison of the performance of contemporaneous lead models with older and new technologies. No effect on lead longevity, durability, on mode of end of lead service, lead removal independent of function (e.g., for infection), materials, or physiological failure was found due to an operator or anatomical route of venous access. Multifilar silicone rubber insulated leads have longevity (CSR) superior to monofilar silicone rubber leads. The cumulative survival of silicone rubber insulated monofilar models 6901, 6907, continuous lead (CL), 4 mm, and 2 mm was 79%-91%, 20 years after implantation. Multifilar silicone rubber insulated models 6961 and 4116 had a cumulative survival of 99%-100%, 15 years after implantation. Among multifilar polyurethane insulated leads, distinct longevity differences exist between formulations and contemporaneous models that are normally similar, yielding a bimodal longevity distinction; model 6971 (ventricular) has 95% CSR and 6991U (atrial) has 94% CSR, 10 years after implantation. Both performed less well than other contemporaneous models, which approximate 100% CSR. The 10-year CSR for leads implanted between 1960-1975 (Era 1) is 98.7%, and the 10-year CSR of leads implanted between 1981-1985 (Era 3) is 99.4%. Comparison of individual lead models, and all leads of specific eras, allows development of survival expectations and standards of quality for comparison between contemporaneous lead models and different eras of manufacture. As the highest available lead CSR sets the standard, statistical deviation era model from the best performance of a specific era should be considered as an indication of reduced quality.

AB - The functional details of all 5,405 pacemaker leads implanted on Montefiore Medical Center were contemporaneously recorded between 1960 and May 31, 1993. Some models have been observed for as long as 24 years. Ventricular leads with more than 50 and atrial leads with more than 30 implanted units have been continually and repeatedly subjected to actuarial cumulative survival rate (CSR) analysis during which clinical decisions, such as continued lead implantation, cessation of use, or early withdrawal from service, were made. CSR evaluation for many lead models by the Mantel- Haenszel method allowed comparison of the performance of contemporaneous lead models with older and new technologies. No effect on lead longevity, durability, on mode of end of lead service, lead removal independent of function (e.g., for infection), materials, or physiological failure was found due to an operator or anatomical route of venous access. Multifilar silicone rubber insulated leads have longevity (CSR) superior to monofilar silicone rubber leads. The cumulative survival of silicone rubber insulated monofilar models 6901, 6907, continuous lead (CL), 4 mm, and 2 mm was 79%-91%, 20 years after implantation. Multifilar silicone rubber insulated models 6961 and 4116 had a cumulative survival of 99%-100%, 15 years after implantation. Among multifilar polyurethane insulated leads, distinct longevity differences exist between formulations and contemporaneous models that are normally similar, yielding a bimodal longevity distinction; model 6971 (ventricular) has 95% CSR and 6991U (atrial) has 94% CSR, 10 years after implantation. Both performed less well than other contemporaneous models, which approximate 100% CSR. The 10-year CSR for leads implanted between 1960-1975 (Era 1) is 98.7%, and the 10-year CSR of leads implanted between 1981-1985 (Era 3) is 99.4%. Comparison of individual lead models, and all leads of specific eras, allows development of survival expectations and standards of quality for comparison between contemporaneous lead models and different eras of manufacture. As the highest available lead CSR sets the standard, statistical deviation era model from the best performance of a specific era should be considered as an indication of reduced quality.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0028894429&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0028894429&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1540-8159.1995.tb02517.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1540-8159.1995.tb02517.x

M3 - Article

VL - 18

SP - 271

EP - 285

JO - PACE - Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology

JF - PACE - Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology

SN - 0147-8389

IS - 2

ER -