Effects of a multipronged beverage intervention on young children's beverage intake and weight: A cluster-randomized pilot study

Anna H. Grummon, Michael D. Cabana, Amelie A. Hecht, Abbey Alkon, Charles E. McCulloch, Claire D. Brindis, Anisha I. Patel

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objective:To evaluate whether a multipronged pilot intervention promoting healthier beverage consumption improved at-home beverage consumption and weight status among young children.Design:In this exploratory pilot study, we randomly assigned four childcare centres to a control (delayed-intervention) condition or a 12-week intervention that promoted consumption of healthier beverages (water, unsweetened low- or non-fat milk) and discouraged consumption of less-healthy beverages (juice, sugar-sweetened beverages, high-fat or sweetened milk). The multipronged intervention was delivered via childcare centres; simultaneously targeted children, parents and childcare staff; and included environmental changes, policies and education. Outcomes were measured at baseline and immediately post-intervention and included children's (n 154) at-home beverage consumption (assessed via parental report) and overweight/obese status (assessed via objectively measured height and weight). We estimated intervention impact using difference-in-differences models controlling for children's demographics and classroom.Setting:Two northern California cities, USA, 2013-2014.Participants:Children aged 2-5 years and their parents.Results:Relative to control group children, intervention group children reduced their consumption of less-healthy beverages from baseline to follow-up by 5·9 ounces/d (95 % CI -11·2, -0·6) (-174·5 ml/d; 95 % CI -331·2, -17·7) and increased their consumption of healthier beverages by 3·5 ounces/d (95 % CI -2·6, 9·5) (103·5 ml/d; 95 % CI -76·9, 280·9). Children's likelihood of being overweight decreased by 3 percentage points (pp) in the intervention group and increased by 3 pp in the control group (difference-in-differences: -6 pp; 95 % CI -15, 3).Conclusions:Our exploratory pilot study suggests that interventions focused comprehensively on encouraging healthier beverage consumption could improve children's beverage intake and weight. Findings should be confirmed in longer, larger studies.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalPublic Health Nutrition
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2019
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Beverages
Weights and Measures
Milk
Parents
Environmental Policy
Control Groups
Fats
Demography
Education
Water

Keywords

  • Beverage consumption
  • Child care
  • Early childhood
  • Obesity prevention intervention
  • Overweight/obesity
  • Sugar-sweetened beverages
  • Water

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine (miscellaneous)
  • Nutrition and Dietetics
  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health

Cite this

Effects of a multipronged beverage intervention on young children's beverage intake and weight : A cluster-randomized pilot study. / Grummon, Anna H.; Cabana, Michael D.; Hecht, Amelie A.; Alkon, Abbey; McCulloch, Charles E.; Brindis, Claire D.; Patel, Anisha I.

In: Public Health Nutrition, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Grummon, Anna H. ; Cabana, Michael D. ; Hecht, Amelie A. ; Alkon, Abbey ; McCulloch, Charles E. ; Brindis, Claire D. ; Patel, Anisha I. / Effects of a multipronged beverage intervention on young children's beverage intake and weight : A cluster-randomized pilot study. In: Public Health Nutrition. 2019.
@article{e98abab6c8984774ab9345d717f95cac,
title = "Effects of a multipronged beverage intervention on young children's beverage intake and weight: A cluster-randomized pilot study",
abstract = "Objective:To evaluate whether a multipronged pilot intervention promoting healthier beverage consumption improved at-home beverage consumption and weight status among young children.Design:In this exploratory pilot study, we randomly assigned four childcare centres to a control (delayed-intervention) condition or a 12-week intervention that promoted consumption of healthier beverages (water, unsweetened low- or non-fat milk) and discouraged consumption of less-healthy beverages (juice, sugar-sweetened beverages, high-fat or sweetened milk). The multipronged intervention was delivered via childcare centres; simultaneously targeted children, parents and childcare staff; and included environmental changes, policies and education. Outcomes were measured at baseline and immediately post-intervention and included children's (n 154) at-home beverage consumption (assessed via parental report) and overweight/obese status (assessed via objectively measured height and weight). We estimated intervention impact using difference-in-differences models controlling for children's demographics and classroom.Setting:Two northern California cities, USA, 2013-2014.Participants:Children aged 2-5 years and their parents.Results:Relative to control group children, intervention group children reduced their consumption of less-healthy beverages from baseline to follow-up by 5·9 ounces/d (95 {\%} CI -11·2, -0·6) (-174·5 ml/d; 95 {\%} CI -331·2, -17·7) and increased their consumption of healthier beverages by 3·5 ounces/d (95 {\%} CI -2·6, 9·5) (103·5 ml/d; 95 {\%} CI -76·9, 280·9). Children's likelihood of being overweight decreased by 3 percentage points (pp) in the intervention group and increased by 3 pp in the control group (difference-in-differences: -6 pp; 95 {\%} CI -15, 3).Conclusions:Our exploratory pilot study suggests that interventions focused comprehensively on encouraging healthier beverage consumption could improve children's beverage intake and weight. Findings should be confirmed in longer, larger studies.",
keywords = "Beverage consumption, Child care, Early childhood, Obesity prevention intervention, Overweight/obesity, Sugar-sweetened beverages, Water",
author = "Grummon, {Anna H.} and Cabana, {Michael D.} and Hecht, {Amelie A.} and Abbey Alkon and McCulloch, {Charles E.} and Brindis, {Claire D.} and Patel, {Anisha I.}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1017/S1368980019001629",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Public Health Nutrition",
issn = "1368-9800",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Effects of a multipronged beverage intervention on young children's beverage intake and weight

T2 - A cluster-randomized pilot study

AU - Grummon, Anna H.

AU - Cabana, Michael D.

AU - Hecht, Amelie A.

AU - Alkon, Abbey

AU - McCulloch, Charles E.

AU - Brindis, Claire D.

AU - Patel, Anisha I.

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Objective:To evaluate whether a multipronged pilot intervention promoting healthier beverage consumption improved at-home beverage consumption and weight status among young children.Design:In this exploratory pilot study, we randomly assigned four childcare centres to a control (delayed-intervention) condition or a 12-week intervention that promoted consumption of healthier beverages (water, unsweetened low- or non-fat milk) and discouraged consumption of less-healthy beverages (juice, sugar-sweetened beverages, high-fat or sweetened milk). The multipronged intervention was delivered via childcare centres; simultaneously targeted children, parents and childcare staff; and included environmental changes, policies and education. Outcomes were measured at baseline and immediately post-intervention and included children's (n 154) at-home beverage consumption (assessed via parental report) and overweight/obese status (assessed via objectively measured height and weight). We estimated intervention impact using difference-in-differences models controlling for children's demographics and classroom.Setting:Two northern California cities, USA, 2013-2014.Participants:Children aged 2-5 years and their parents.Results:Relative to control group children, intervention group children reduced their consumption of less-healthy beverages from baseline to follow-up by 5·9 ounces/d (95 % CI -11·2, -0·6) (-174·5 ml/d; 95 % CI -331·2, -17·7) and increased their consumption of healthier beverages by 3·5 ounces/d (95 % CI -2·6, 9·5) (103·5 ml/d; 95 % CI -76·9, 280·9). Children's likelihood of being overweight decreased by 3 percentage points (pp) in the intervention group and increased by 3 pp in the control group (difference-in-differences: -6 pp; 95 % CI -15, 3).Conclusions:Our exploratory pilot study suggests that interventions focused comprehensively on encouraging healthier beverage consumption could improve children's beverage intake and weight. Findings should be confirmed in longer, larger studies.

AB - Objective:To evaluate whether a multipronged pilot intervention promoting healthier beverage consumption improved at-home beverage consumption and weight status among young children.Design:In this exploratory pilot study, we randomly assigned four childcare centres to a control (delayed-intervention) condition or a 12-week intervention that promoted consumption of healthier beverages (water, unsweetened low- or non-fat milk) and discouraged consumption of less-healthy beverages (juice, sugar-sweetened beverages, high-fat or sweetened milk). The multipronged intervention was delivered via childcare centres; simultaneously targeted children, parents and childcare staff; and included environmental changes, policies and education. Outcomes were measured at baseline and immediately post-intervention and included children's (n 154) at-home beverage consumption (assessed via parental report) and overweight/obese status (assessed via objectively measured height and weight). We estimated intervention impact using difference-in-differences models controlling for children's demographics and classroom.Setting:Two northern California cities, USA, 2013-2014.Participants:Children aged 2-5 years and their parents.Results:Relative to control group children, intervention group children reduced their consumption of less-healthy beverages from baseline to follow-up by 5·9 ounces/d (95 % CI -11·2, -0·6) (-174·5 ml/d; 95 % CI -331·2, -17·7) and increased their consumption of healthier beverages by 3·5 ounces/d (95 % CI -2·6, 9·5) (103·5 ml/d; 95 % CI -76·9, 280·9). Children's likelihood of being overweight decreased by 3 percentage points (pp) in the intervention group and increased by 3 pp in the control group (difference-in-differences: -6 pp; 95 % CI -15, 3).Conclusions:Our exploratory pilot study suggests that interventions focused comprehensively on encouraging healthier beverage consumption could improve children's beverage intake and weight. Findings should be confirmed in longer, larger studies.

KW - Beverage consumption

KW - Child care

KW - Early childhood

KW - Obesity prevention intervention

KW - Overweight/obesity

KW - Sugar-sweetened beverages

KW - Water

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85069164311&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85069164311&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1017/S1368980019001629

DO - 10.1017/S1368980019001629

M3 - Article

C2 - 31303190

AN - SCOPUS:85069164311

JO - Public Health Nutrition

JF - Public Health Nutrition

SN - 1368-9800

ER -