Beyond satisfaction

Using the dynamics of care assessment to better understand patients' experiences in care

Bruce D. Rapkin, Elisa Weiss, Rosy Chhabra, Laura Ryniker, Shilpa Patel, Jason Carness, Roberto Adsuar, Wendy Kahalas, Carol DeLeMarter, Ira Feldman, Judy DeLorenzo, Ellen Tanner

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

26 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: Patient perceptions of and satisfaction with care have become important indicators of the quality of services and the relationship of services to treatment outcomes. However, assessment of these indicators continues to be plagued by measurement problems, particularly the lack of variance in satisfaction data. In this article, we present a new approach to better capture patient perceptions of experiences in care, the Dynamics of Care (DoC) assessment. It is an in-depth approach to defining and assessing patients' perspectives at different junctures in care, including their decisions about whether and where to seek care, the barriers encountered, and the treatments and services received. Methods: The purpose of this article is to describe, validate, and discuss the benefits and limitations of the DoC, which was administered as part of a longitudinal study to evaluate the New York State HIV Special Needs Plan (SNP), a Medicaid managed care model for people living with HIV/AIDS. Data are from 426 study respondents across two time points. Results: The results demonstrate the validity and value of the DoC. Help seeking decisions and satisfaction with care appear to be situation-specific, rather than person-specific. However, barriers to care appear to be more cross-situational for respondents, and may be associated with clients' living situations or care arrangements. Inventories in this assessment that were designed to identify potential deterrents to help seeking and difficulties encountered in care demonstrated clear principal component structures, and helped to explain satisfaction with care. The problem resolution index was found to be independent from satisfaction with care and the data were more normally distributed. DoC data were also associated with subsequent utilization and change in quality of life. Conclusion: The DoC was designed to be aflexible, integrated measure to determine individuals' salient service needs, help seeking and experiences in care. One of the many strengths of the assessment is its focus on specific problems in context, thus providing a more sensitive and informative way to understand processes in care from the patient's perspective. This approach can be used to direct new programs and resources to the patients and situations that require them.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number20
JournalHealth and Quality of Life Outcomes
Volume6
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 10 2008

Fingerprint

HIV
Medicaid
Managed Care Programs
Patient Satisfaction
Reproducibility of Results
Longitudinal Studies
Patient Care
Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome
Quality of Life
Equipment and Supplies
Surveys and Questionnaires
Therapeutics

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health

Cite this

Beyond satisfaction : Using the dynamics of care assessment to better understand patients' experiences in care. / Rapkin, Bruce D.; Weiss, Elisa; Chhabra, Rosy; Ryniker, Laura; Patel, Shilpa; Carness, Jason; Adsuar, Roberto; Kahalas, Wendy; DeLeMarter, Carol; Feldman, Ira; DeLorenzo, Judy; Tanner, Ellen.

In: Health and Quality of Life Outcomes, Vol. 6, 20, 10.03.2008.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Rapkin, BD, Weiss, E, Chhabra, R, Ryniker, L, Patel, S, Carness, J, Adsuar, R, Kahalas, W, DeLeMarter, C, Feldman, I, DeLorenzo, J & Tanner, E 2008, 'Beyond satisfaction: Using the dynamics of care assessment to better understand patients' experiences in care', Health and Quality of Life Outcomes, vol. 6, 20. https://doi.org/10.1186/1477-7525-6-20
Rapkin, Bruce D. ; Weiss, Elisa ; Chhabra, Rosy ; Ryniker, Laura ; Patel, Shilpa ; Carness, Jason ; Adsuar, Roberto ; Kahalas, Wendy ; DeLeMarter, Carol ; Feldman, Ira ; DeLorenzo, Judy ; Tanner, Ellen. / Beyond satisfaction : Using the dynamics of care assessment to better understand patients' experiences in care. In: Health and Quality of Life Outcomes. 2008 ; Vol. 6.
@article{307df438b84f41d49360530a4dfe5d24,
title = "Beyond satisfaction: Using the dynamics of care assessment to better understand patients' experiences in care",
abstract = "Background: Patient perceptions of and satisfaction with care have become important indicators of the quality of services and the relationship of services to treatment outcomes. However, assessment of these indicators continues to be plagued by measurement problems, particularly the lack of variance in satisfaction data. In this article, we present a new approach to better capture patient perceptions of experiences in care, the Dynamics of Care (DoC) assessment. It is an in-depth approach to defining and assessing patients' perspectives at different junctures in care, including their decisions about whether and where to seek care, the barriers encountered, and the treatments and services received. Methods: The purpose of this article is to describe, validate, and discuss the benefits and limitations of the DoC, which was administered as part of a longitudinal study to evaluate the New York State HIV Special Needs Plan (SNP), a Medicaid managed care model for people living with HIV/AIDS. Data are from 426 study respondents across two time points. Results: The results demonstrate the validity and value of the DoC. Help seeking decisions and satisfaction with care appear to be situation-specific, rather than person-specific. However, barriers to care appear to be more cross-situational for respondents, and may be associated with clients' living situations or care arrangements. Inventories in this assessment that were designed to identify potential deterrents to help seeking and difficulties encountered in care demonstrated clear principal component structures, and helped to explain satisfaction with care. The problem resolution index was found to be independent from satisfaction with care and the data were more normally distributed. DoC data were also associated with subsequent utilization and change in quality of life. Conclusion: The DoC was designed to be aflexible, integrated measure to determine individuals' salient service needs, help seeking and experiences in care. One of the many strengths of the assessment is its focus on specific problems in context, thus providing a more sensitive and informative way to understand processes in care from the patient's perspective. This approach can be used to direct new programs and resources to the patients and situations that require them.",
author = "Rapkin, {Bruce D.} and Elisa Weiss and Rosy Chhabra and Laura Ryniker and Shilpa Patel and Jason Carness and Roberto Adsuar and Wendy Kahalas and Carol DeLeMarter and Ira Feldman and Judy DeLorenzo and Ellen Tanner",
year = "2008",
month = "3",
day = "10",
doi = "10.1186/1477-7525-6-20",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "6",
journal = "Health and Quality of Life Outcomes",
issn = "1477-7525",
publisher = "BioMed Central",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Beyond satisfaction

T2 - Using the dynamics of care assessment to better understand patients' experiences in care

AU - Rapkin, Bruce D.

AU - Weiss, Elisa

AU - Chhabra, Rosy

AU - Ryniker, Laura

AU - Patel, Shilpa

AU - Carness, Jason

AU - Adsuar, Roberto

AU - Kahalas, Wendy

AU - DeLeMarter, Carol

AU - Feldman, Ira

AU - DeLorenzo, Judy

AU - Tanner, Ellen

PY - 2008/3/10

Y1 - 2008/3/10

N2 - Background: Patient perceptions of and satisfaction with care have become important indicators of the quality of services and the relationship of services to treatment outcomes. However, assessment of these indicators continues to be plagued by measurement problems, particularly the lack of variance in satisfaction data. In this article, we present a new approach to better capture patient perceptions of experiences in care, the Dynamics of Care (DoC) assessment. It is an in-depth approach to defining and assessing patients' perspectives at different junctures in care, including their decisions about whether and where to seek care, the barriers encountered, and the treatments and services received. Methods: The purpose of this article is to describe, validate, and discuss the benefits and limitations of the DoC, which was administered as part of a longitudinal study to evaluate the New York State HIV Special Needs Plan (SNP), a Medicaid managed care model for people living with HIV/AIDS. Data are from 426 study respondents across two time points. Results: The results demonstrate the validity and value of the DoC. Help seeking decisions and satisfaction with care appear to be situation-specific, rather than person-specific. However, barriers to care appear to be more cross-situational for respondents, and may be associated with clients' living situations or care arrangements. Inventories in this assessment that were designed to identify potential deterrents to help seeking and difficulties encountered in care demonstrated clear principal component structures, and helped to explain satisfaction with care. The problem resolution index was found to be independent from satisfaction with care and the data were more normally distributed. DoC data were also associated with subsequent utilization and change in quality of life. Conclusion: The DoC was designed to be aflexible, integrated measure to determine individuals' salient service needs, help seeking and experiences in care. One of the many strengths of the assessment is its focus on specific problems in context, thus providing a more sensitive and informative way to understand processes in care from the patient's perspective. This approach can be used to direct new programs and resources to the patients and situations that require them.

AB - Background: Patient perceptions of and satisfaction with care have become important indicators of the quality of services and the relationship of services to treatment outcomes. However, assessment of these indicators continues to be plagued by measurement problems, particularly the lack of variance in satisfaction data. In this article, we present a new approach to better capture patient perceptions of experiences in care, the Dynamics of Care (DoC) assessment. It is an in-depth approach to defining and assessing patients' perspectives at different junctures in care, including their decisions about whether and where to seek care, the barriers encountered, and the treatments and services received. Methods: The purpose of this article is to describe, validate, and discuss the benefits and limitations of the DoC, which was administered as part of a longitudinal study to evaluate the New York State HIV Special Needs Plan (SNP), a Medicaid managed care model for people living with HIV/AIDS. Data are from 426 study respondents across two time points. Results: The results demonstrate the validity and value of the DoC. Help seeking decisions and satisfaction with care appear to be situation-specific, rather than person-specific. However, barriers to care appear to be more cross-situational for respondents, and may be associated with clients' living situations or care arrangements. Inventories in this assessment that were designed to identify potential deterrents to help seeking and difficulties encountered in care demonstrated clear principal component structures, and helped to explain satisfaction with care. The problem resolution index was found to be independent from satisfaction with care and the data were more normally distributed. DoC data were also associated with subsequent utilization and change in quality of life. Conclusion: The DoC was designed to be aflexible, integrated measure to determine individuals' salient service needs, help seeking and experiences in care. One of the many strengths of the assessment is its focus on specific problems in context, thus providing a more sensitive and informative way to understand processes in care from the patient's perspective. This approach can be used to direct new programs and resources to the patients and situations that require them.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=42549153489&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=42549153489&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/1477-7525-6-20

DO - 10.1186/1477-7525-6-20

M3 - Article

VL - 6

JO - Health and Quality of Life Outcomes

JF - Health and Quality of Life Outcomes

SN - 1477-7525

M1 - 20

ER -