Barriers to Behavioral Treatment Adherence for Headache: An Examination of Attitudes, Beliefs, and Psychiatric Factors

Yuka Matsuzawa, Yuen Shan Christine Lee, Felicia Fraser, Donna Langenbahn, Amanda Shallcross, Scott Powers, Richard B. Lipton, Naomi Simon, Mia Minen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background/Objectives: Nonpharmacological interventions, such as biofeedback, cognitive behavioral therapy, and relaxation techniques are Level-A evidence-based treatments for headache. The impact of these interventions is often equivalent to or greater than pharmacological interventions, with fewer side effects. Despite such evidence, the rate of participation in nonpharmacological interventions for headache remains low. Once obstacles to optimizing use of behavioral interventions, such as local access to nonpharmacological treatment and primary headache providers are traversed, identification of barriers contributing to low adherence is imperative given the high levels of disability and cost associated with treating headache disorders. In this review of factors in adults associated with underuse of nonpharmacological interventions, we discuss psychological factors relevant to participation in nonpharmacological treatment, including attitudes and beliefs, motivation for change, awareness of triggers, locus of control, self-efficacy, acceptance, coping styles, personality traits, and psychiatric comorbidities associated with treatment adherence. Finally, future prospects and approaches to optimizing treatment matching and minimizing adherence issues are addressed. Methods: An interdisciplinary team conducted this narrative review. Neuropsychologists conducted a literature search during the month of July 2017 using a combination of the keywords (“headache” or “migraine”) and (“adherence” or “compliance”) or “barriers to treatment” or various “psychological factors” discussed in this narrative review. Content experts, a psychiatrist, and a complementary and integrative health specialist provided additional commentary and input to this narrative review resulting in integration of additional noteworthy studies, book chapters and books. Results: Various psychological factors, such as attitudes and beliefs, lack of motivation, poor awareness of triggers, external locus of control, poor self-efficacy, low levels of acceptance, and engagement in maladaptive coping styles can contribute to nonadherence. Conclusions: To maximize adherence, clinicians can assess and address an individual’s level of treatment acceptance, beliefs that may present as barriers, readiness for change, locus of control, self-efficacy and psychiatric comorbidities. Identification of barriers to adherence as well as the application of relevant assessment and intervention techniques have the potential to facilitate adherence and ultimately improve treatment success.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalHeadache
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2018

Fingerprint

Headache
Psychiatry
Internal-External Control
Self Efficacy
Psychology
Therapeutics
Comorbidity
Motivation
Relaxation Therapy
Headache Disorders
Cognitive Therapy
Migraine Disorders
Compliance
Personality
Pharmacology
Costs and Cost Analysis
Health

Keywords

  • barriers to adherence
  • headache
  • nonpharmacological interventions
  • psychological factors

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Neurology
  • Clinical Neurology

Cite this

Matsuzawa, Y., Lee, Y. S. C., Fraser, F., Langenbahn, D., Shallcross, A., Powers, S., ... Minen, M. (Accepted/In press). Barriers to Behavioral Treatment Adherence for Headache: An Examination of Attitudes, Beliefs, and Psychiatric Factors. Headache. https://doi.org/10.1111/head.13429

Barriers to Behavioral Treatment Adherence for Headache : An Examination of Attitudes, Beliefs, and Psychiatric Factors. / Matsuzawa, Yuka; Lee, Yuen Shan Christine; Fraser, Felicia; Langenbahn, Donna; Shallcross, Amanda; Powers, Scott; Lipton, Richard B.; Simon, Naomi; Minen, Mia.

In: Headache, 01.01.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Matsuzawa, Yuka ; Lee, Yuen Shan Christine ; Fraser, Felicia ; Langenbahn, Donna ; Shallcross, Amanda ; Powers, Scott ; Lipton, Richard B. ; Simon, Naomi ; Minen, Mia. / Barriers to Behavioral Treatment Adherence for Headache : An Examination of Attitudes, Beliefs, and Psychiatric Factors. In: Headache. 2018.
@article{98d7a0aaf98249af8de020c79a8557db,
title = "Barriers to Behavioral Treatment Adherence for Headache: An Examination of Attitudes, Beliefs, and Psychiatric Factors",
abstract = "Background/Objectives: Nonpharmacological interventions, such as biofeedback, cognitive behavioral therapy, and relaxation techniques are Level-A evidence-based treatments for headache. The impact of these interventions is often equivalent to or greater than pharmacological interventions, with fewer side effects. Despite such evidence, the rate of participation in nonpharmacological interventions for headache remains low. Once obstacles to optimizing use of behavioral interventions, such as local access to nonpharmacological treatment and primary headache providers are traversed, identification of barriers contributing to low adherence is imperative given the high levels of disability and cost associated with treating headache disorders. In this review of factors in adults associated with underuse of nonpharmacological interventions, we discuss psychological factors relevant to participation in nonpharmacological treatment, including attitudes and beliefs, motivation for change, awareness of triggers, locus of control, self-efficacy, acceptance, coping styles, personality traits, and psychiatric comorbidities associated with treatment adherence. Finally, future prospects and approaches to optimizing treatment matching and minimizing adherence issues are addressed. Methods: An interdisciplinary team conducted this narrative review. Neuropsychologists conducted a literature search during the month of July 2017 using a combination of the keywords (“headache” or “migraine”) and (“adherence” or “compliance”) or “barriers to treatment” or various “psychological factors” discussed in this narrative review. Content experts, a psychiatrist, and a complementary and integrative health specialist provided additional commentary and input to this narrative review resulting in integration of additional noteworthy studies, book chapters and books. Results: Various psychological factors, such as attitudes and beliefs, lack of motivation, poor awareness of triggers, external locus of control, poor self-efficacy, low levels of acceptance, and engagement in maladaptive coping styles can contribute to nonadherence. Conclusions: To maximize adherence, clinicians can assess and address an individual’s level of treatment acceptance, beliefs that may present as barriers, readiness for change, locus of control, self-efficacy and psychiatric comorbidities. Identification of barriers to adherence as well as the application of relevant assessment and intervention techniques have the potential to facilitate adherence and ultimately improve treatment success.",
keywords = "barriers to adherence, headache, nonpharmacological interventions, psychological factors",
author = "Yuka Matsuzawa and Lee, {Yuen Shan Christine} and Felicia Fraser and Donna Langenbahn and Amanda Shallcross and Scott Powers and Lipton, {Richard B.} and Naomi Simon and Mia Minen",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/head.13429",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Headache",
issn = "0017-8748",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Barriers to Behavioral Treatment Adherence for Headache

T2 - An Examination of Attitudes, Beliefs, and Psychiatric Factors

AU - Matsuzawa, Yuka

AU - Lee, Yuen Shan Christine

AU - Fraser, Felicia

AU - Langenbahn, Donna

AU - Shallcross, Amanda

AU - Powers, Scott

AU - Lipton, Richard B.

AU - Simon, Naomi

AU - Minen, Mia

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - Background/Objectives: Nonpharmacological interventions, such as biofeedback, cognitive behavioral therapy, and relaxation techniques are Level-A evidence-based treatments for headache. The impact of these interventions is often equivalent to or greater than pharmacological interventions, with fewer side effects. Despite such evidence, the rate of participation in nonpharmacological interventions for headache remains low. Once obstacles to optimizing use of behavioral interventions, such as local access to nonpharmacological treatment and primary headache providers are traversed, identification of barriers contributing to low adherence is imperative given the high levels of disability and cost associated with treating headache disorders. In this review of factors in adults associated with underuse of nonpharmacological interventions, we discuss psychological factors relevant to participation in nonpharmacological treatment, including attitudes and beliefs, motivation for change, awareness of triggers, locus of control, self-efficacy, acceptance, coping styles, personality traits, and psychiatric comorbidities associated with treatment adherence. Finally, future prospects and approaches to optimizing treatment matching and minimizing adherence issues are addressed. Methods: An interdisciplinary team conducted this narrative review. Neuropsychologists conducted a literature search during the month of July 2017 using a combination of the keywords (“headache” or “migraine”) and (“adherence” or “compliance”) or “barriers to treatment” or various “psychological factors” discussed in this narrative review. Content experts, a psychiatrist, and a complementary and integrative health specialist provided additional commentary and input to this narrative review resulting in integration of additional noteworthy studies, book chapters and books. Results: Various psychological factors, such as attitudes and beliefs, lack of motivation, poor awareness of triggers, external locus of control, poor self-efficacy, low levels of acceptance, and engagement in maladaptive coping styles can contribute to nonadherence. Conclusions: To maximize adherence, clinicians can assess and address an individual’s level of treatment acceptance, beliefs that may present as barriers, readiness for change, locus of control, self-efficacy and psychiatric comorbidities. Identification of barriers to adherence as well as the application of relevant assessment and intervention techniques have the potential to facilitate adherence and ultimately improve treatment success.

AB - Background/Objectives: Nonpharmacological interventions, such as biofeedback, cognitive behavioral therapy, and relaxation techniques are Level-A evidence-based treatments for headache. The impact of these interventions is often equivalent to or greater than pharmacological interventions, with fewer side effects. Despite such evidence, the rate of participation in nonpharmacological interventions for headache remains low. Once obstacles to optimizing use of behavioral interventions, such as local access to nonpharmacological treatment and primary headache providers are traversed, identification of barriers contributing to low adherence is imperative given the high levels of disability and cost associated with treating headache disorders. In this review of factors in adults associated with underuse of nonpharmacological interventions, we discuss psychological factors relevant to participation in nonpharmacological treatment, including attitudes and beliefs, motivation for change, awareness of triggers, locus of control, self-efficacy, acceptance, coping styles, personality traits, and psychiatric comorbidities associated with treatment adherence. Finally, future prospects and approaches to optimizing treatment matching and minimizing adherence issues are addressed. Methods: An interdisciplinary team conducted this narrative review. Neuropsychologists conducted a literature search during the month of July 2017 using a combination of the keywords (“headache” or “migraine”) and (“adherence” or “compliance”) or “barriers to treatment” or various “psychological factors” discussed in this narrative review. Content experts, a psychiatrist, and a complementary and integrative health specialist provided additional commentary and input to this narrative review resulting in integration of additional noteworthy studies, book chapters and books. Results: Various psychological factors, such as attitudes and beliefs, lack of motivation, poor awareness of triggers, external locus of control, poor self-efficacy, low levels of acceptance, and engagement in maladaptive coping styles can contribute to nonadherence. Conclusions: To maximize adherence, clinicians can assess and address an individual’s level of treatment acceptance, beliefs that may present as barriers, readiness for change, locus of control, self-efficacy and psychiatric comorbidities. Identification of barriers to adherence as well as the application of relevant assessment and intervention techniques have the potential to facilitate adherence and ultimately improve treatment success.

KW - barriers to adherence

KW - headache

KW - nonpharmacological interventions

KW - psychological factors

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85055471610&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85055471610&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/head.13429

DO - 10.1111/head.13429

M3 - Article

C2 - 30367821

AN - SCOPUS:85055471610

JO - Headache

JF - Headache

SN - 0017-8748

ER -