Aesthetic breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons

Peter Niclas Broer, Sabrina Juran, Marc E. Walker, Reuben Ng, Katie E. Weichman, Neil Tanna, Yuen Jong Liu, Ajul Shah, Anup Patel, John A. Persing, James Grant Thomson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background There has been little discussion in the plastic surgery literature regarding breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons, despite strong evidence that such aesthetic preferences are influenced by multiple factors. Much effort has been focused on delineating the objective criteria by which an "attractive" breast might be defined. This study aimed at providing a better understanding of the presence and significance of differences in personal aesthetic perception, and how these relate to a plastic surgeon's demographic, ethnic, and cultural background, as well as practice type (academic vs private). Methods An interactive online survey was designed. Modifiable ranges of upper pole fullness and areola size were achieved via digital alteration, enabling participants to interactively change the shape of a model's breasts. The questionnaire was translated into multiple languages and sent to plastic surgeons worldwide. Demographic data were also collected. Analysis of variance was used to elucidate plastic surgeon's breast shape preferences in respect to sex and age, geographic and ethnic background, as well as practice type. Results The authors gathered 614 responses from 29 different countries. Significant differences regarding preferences for upper pole fullness, areola size in the natural breast, and areola size in the augmented breast were identified across surgeons from the different countries. Further, significant relationships regarding breast shape preferences were distilled between the age and sex of the surgeon, as well as the practice type. No differences were found in respect to the surgeons' self-reported ethnic background. Conclusions Country of residence, age, and practice type significantly impact breast shape preferences of plastic surgeons. These findings have implications for both patients seeking and surgeons performing cosmetic and reconstructive breast surgery. In an increasingly global environment, cultural differences and international variability must be considered when defining and publishing new techniques and aesthetic outcomes. When both the plastic surgeon and the patient are able to adequately and effectively communicate their preferences regarding the shape and relations of the breast, they will be more successful at achieving satisfying results.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)639-644
Number of pages6
JournalAnnals of Plastic Surgery
Volume74
Issue number6
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 26 2015
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Esthetics
Breast
Nipples
Reconstructive Surgical Procedures
Demography
Surgeons
Plastic Surgery
Analysis of Variance
Language

Keywords

  • aesthetics
  • age
  • augmentation
  • breast
  • breast shape
  • ethnic and cultural background
  • international
  • practice
  • preferences

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery

Cite this

Broer, P. N., Juran, S., Walker, M. E., Ng, R., Weichman, K. E., Tanna, N., ... Thomson, J. G. (2015). Aesthetic breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons. Annals of Plastic Surgery, 74(6), 639-644. https://doi.org/10.1097/SAP.0000000000000001

Aesthetic breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons. / Broer, Peter Niclas; Juran, Sabrina; Walker, Marc E.; Ng, Reuben; Weichman, Katie E.; Tanna, Neil; Liu, Yuen Jong; Shah, Ajul; Patel, Anup; Persing, John A.; Thomson, James Grant.

In: Annals of Plastic Surgery, Vol. 74, No. 6, 26.06.2015, p. 639-644.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Broer, PN, Juran, S, Walker, ME, Ng, R, Weichman, KE, Tanna, N, Liu, YJ, Shah, A, Patel, A, Persing, JA & Thomson, JG 2015, 'Aesthetic breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons', Annals of Plastic Surgery, vol. 74, no. 6, pp. 639-644. https://doi.org/10.1097/SAP.0000000000000001
Broer, Peter Niclas ; Juran, Sabrina ; Walker, Marc E. ; Ng, Reuben ; Weichman, Katie E. ; Tanna, Neil ; Liu, Yuen Jong ; Shah, Ajul ; Patel, Anup ; Persing, John A. ; Thomson, James Grant. / Aesthetic breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons. In: Annals of Plastic Surgery. 2015 ; Vol. 74, No. 6. pp. 639-644.
@article{c07083c6d67b4dedbba4e2bc142fc43c,
title = "Aesthetic breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons",
abstract = "Background There has been little discussion in the plastic surgery literature regarding breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons, despite strong evidence that such aesthetic preferences are influenced by multiple factors. Much effort has been focused on delineating the objective criteria by which an {"}attractive{"} breast might be defined. This study aimed at providing a better understanding of the presence and significance of differences in personal aesthetic perception, and how these relate to a plastic surgeon's demographic, ethnic, and cultural background, as well as practice type (academic vs private). Methods An interactive online survey was designed. Modifiable ranges of upper pole fullness and areola size were achieved via digital alteration, enabling participants to interactively change the shape of a model's breasts. The questionnaire was translated into multiple languages and sent to plastic surgeons worldwide. Demographic data were also collected. Analysis of variance was used to elucidate plastic surgeon's breast shape preferences in respect to sex and age, geographic and ethnic background, as well as practice type. Results The authors gathered 614 responses from 29 different countries. Significant differences regarding preferences for upper pole fullness, areola size in the natural breast, and areola size in the augmented breast were identified across surgeons from the different countries. Further, significant relationships regarding breast shape preferences were distilled between the age and sex of the surgeon, as well as the practice type. No differences were found in respect to the surgeons' self-reported ethnic background. Conclusions Country of residence, age, and practice type significantly impact breast shape preferences of plastic surgeons. These findings have implications for both patients seeking and surgeons performing cosmetic and reconstructive breast surgery. In an increasingly global environment, cultural differences and international variability must be considered when defining and publishing new techniques and aesthetic outcomes. When both the plastic surgeon and the patient are able to adequately and effectively communicate their preferences regarding the shape and relations of the breast, they will be more successful at achieving satisfying results.",
keywords = "aesthetics, age, augmentation, breast, breast shape, ethnic and cultural background, international, practice, preferences",
author = "Broer, {Peter Niclas} and Sabrina Juran and Walker, {Marc E.} and Reuben Ng and Weichman, {Katie E.} and Neil Tanna and Liu, {Yuen Jong} and Ajul Shah and Anup Patel and Persing, {John A.} and Thomson, {James Grant}",
year = "2015",
month = "6",
day = "26",
doi = "10.1097/SAP.0000000000000001",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "74",
pages = "639--644",
journal = "Annals of Plastic Surgery",
issn = "0148-7043",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Aesthetic breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons

AU - Broer, Peter Niclas

AU - Juran, Sabrina

AU - Walker, Marc E.

AU - Ng, Reuben

AU - Weichman, Katie E.

AU - Tanna, Neil

AU - Liu, Yuen Jong

AU - Shah, Ajul

AU - Patel, Anup

AU - Persing, John A.

AU - Thomson, James Grant

PY - 2015/6/26

Y1 - 2015/6/26

N2 - Background There has been little discussion in the plastic surgery literature regarding breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons, despite strong evidence that such aesthetic preferences are influenced by multiple factors. Much effort has been focused on delineating the objective criteria by which an "attractive" breast might be defined. This study aimed at providing a better understanding of the presence and significance of differences in personal aesthetic perception, and how these relate to a plastic surgeon's demographic, ethnic, and cultural background, as well as practice type (academic vs private). Methods An interactive online survey was designed. Modifiable ranges of upper pole fullness and areola size were achieved via digital alteration, enabling participants to interactively change the shape of a model's breasts. The questionnaire was translated into multiple languages and sent to plastic surgeons worldwide. Demographic data were also collected. Analysis of variance was used to elucidate plastic surgeon's breast shape preferences in respect to sex and age, geographic and ethnic background, as well as practice type. Results The authors gathered 614 responses from 29 different countries. Significant differences regarding preferences for upper pole fullness, areola size in the natural breast, and areola size in the augmented breast were identified across surgeons from the different countries. Further, significant relationships regarding breast shape preferences were distilled between the age and sex of the surgeon, as well as the practice type. No differences were found in respect to the surgeons' self-reported ethnic background. Conclusions Country of residence, age, and practice type significantly impact breast shape preferences of plastic surgeons. These findings have implications for both patients seeking and surgeons performing cosmetic and reconstructive breast surgery. In an increasingly global environment, cultural differences and international variability must be considered when defining and publishing new techniques and aesthetic outcomes. When both the plastic surgeon and the patient are able to adequately and effectively communicate their preferences regarding the shape and relations of the breast, they will be more successful at achieving satisfying results.

AB - Background There has been little discussion in the plastic surgery literature regarding breast shape preferences among plastic surgeons, despite strong evidence that such aesthetic preferences are influenced by multiple factors. Much effort has been focused on delineating the objective criteria by which an "attractive" breast might be defined. This study aimed at providing a better understanding of the presence and significance of differences in personal aesthetic perception, and how these relate to a plastic surgeon's demographic, ethnic, and cultural background, as well as practice type (academic vs private). Methods An interactive online survey was designed. Modifiable ranges of upper pole fullness and areola size were achieved via digital alteration, enabling participants to interactively change the shape of a model's breasts. The questionnaire was translated into multiple languages and sent to plastic surgeons worldwide. Demographic data were also collected. Analysis of variance was used to elucidate plastic surgeon's breast shape preferences in respect to sex and age, geographic and ethnic background, as well as practice type. Results The authors gathered 614 responses from 29 different countries. Significant differences regarding preferences for upper pole fullness, areola size in the natural breast, and areola size in the augmented breast were identified across surgeons from the different countries. Further, significant relationships regarding breast shape preferences were distilled between the age and sex of the surgeon, as well as the practice type. No differences were found in respect to the surgeons' self-reported ethnic background. Conclusions Country of residence, age, and practice type significantly impact breast shape preferences of plastic surgeons. These findings have implications for both patients seeking and surgeons performing cosmetic and reconstructive breast surgery. In an increasingly global environment, cultural differences and international variability must be considered when defining and publishing new techniques and aesthetic outcomes. When both the plastic surgeon and the patient are able to adequately and effectively communicate their preferences regarding the shape and relations of the breast, they will be more successful at achieving satisfying results.

KW - aesthetics

KW - age

KW - augmentation

KW - breast

KW - breast shape

KW - ethnic and cultural background

KW - international

KW - practice

KW - preferences

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84929945798&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84929945798&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/SAP.0000000000000001

DO - 10.1097/SAP.0000000000000001

M3 - Article

VL - 74

SP - 639

EP - 644

JO - Annals of Plastic Surgery

JF - Annals of Plastic Surgery

SN - 0148-7043

IS - 6

ER -